My dorm room is 94 square feet. It is the smallest room on my floor. It is the smallest room in my whole building. I can’t open my door all the way because it is blocked by my chair. My desk only fits in one corner of the room, so I can’t move my chair. I have to walk into my room sideways. If my backpack is too full, I have to take it off to fit through the door. If I eat too much at Chipotle, it’s not a guarantee that I’ll fit. There is no floor space for my refrigerator, so it is on top of my dresser. I can reach my desk from my bed; I don’t have to get up to grab cereal in the morning.
94 square feet doesn’t always sound that small. There are rooms in my building that are 100 square feet. 103 square feet. 110. They’re all small. The thing about 94 square feet is that it’s cozy in the strangest ways possible. It takes about a minute for the room to absorb the scent of anything I eat. One bowl of pasta and it’s tomato sauce for the next twelve hours. One unfinished cup of coffee and I’m living in a Starbucks for the next day. Usually, that’s not a problem. Maybe I don’t eat a lot of food that stinks up my room. Maybe that means my tastes are too bland. Oh well. I like to tell people that it’s the only benefit of my tiny room. No one believes me, but when your room is too small for the door to open, it’s important to look for the positives.
It’s not all positives, though. There’s no moderating the temperature in a room that’s not ten feet wide. I put my fan on its lowest setting and I can still feel it regardless of where I sit. I thought I would need two fans to make it through August and September. My second fan was stolen off the street on move-in day. I’m still grateful for whoever was kind enough to take it off my hands. It was a tower fan with a broken base. There would be nowhere to put it in my room and there’s a good chance it might blow all of my belongings off of my shelves. One fan is more than enough. If it gets too stuffy, I can crack open my window. Ten minutes later, I’ll be freezing and have to slam the window shut again. It doesn’t take long to ventilate River 203.
I can handle that. It’s almost spring, so it’s not too hot. A little cold draft never bothered me. What I can’t handle are the acoustics. Acoustics might be the wrong word. The problem is really that my room is too small to hold sound. I like to play music at all times, and I like to play it loudly. The problem with a room that’s the size of closets in some homes is that the definition of loud changes very quickly. In my last dorm room, I didn’t have a speaker. I had to play music from my laptop. The sound quality was awful, but, at full volume, it was enough to fill the room. It got the job done when I needed to play something loud to get some work done or to play something loud on a Saturday night. I didn’t mind the lack of quality; volume is really all I care about. Maybe that’s because I wasn’t listening to classical music. It wasn’t even pop or country or indie. It was always rap, the louder and faster the better. It was Migos and Rick Ross and 2 Chainz, stuff where the sound quality really isn’t the point. If it was anything else, my neighbors would stick their heads in the door and ask why the fuck I would be plying anything else. Somehow, those neighbors were louder than me. They had speaker systems and fewer worries about the study habits of the rest of the floor. From nine in the morning to three the next morning the music was heavy and loud. It started at eight in the morning if someone had an 8:40 that day.
I loved it. I could play what I wanted, when I wanted, at whatever volume I wanted. My roommate started the year with different musical tastes. He was all about Top 50 Raggaeton and whatever Pop was at the top of the charts. By winter break, I couldn’t make him take Big Sean off repeat. By the end of the year, he had opinions about rap. He was almost always wrong, but he was hooked. The neighbors and I constantly reminded him that he didn’t know what he was talking about and there were one or two debates that turned into arguments that turned into days where he lost music privileges. Still, it was a good time to be loud and play anything without thinking. My room was 210 square feet. That meant space for noise and music that could spill into the hall and penetrate the walls and take up space.
94 square feet means less space for music. My phone only needs half volume to fill the room. A third of the volume on my laptop speakers is too much. Music starts spilling out the door and into the halls and the lounge and the bathrooms and the janitor’s closet that used to be part of my room before anyone decided 94 square feet was a reasonable living space. It feels ridiculous to play anything loud when I’m never more than a step away from the source of the sound. Really, that’s not much of a problem. It even makes sense in a way. It’s probably better for studying. It’s definitely better for writing. It’s made me transition to the “Chill Vibes” Spotify playlist. I’ve experimented with the “Beach Vibes” playlist. I’m ashamed to say I’ve even tried “Hot Country” and “Country Hits.” That was unthinkable a year ago. There was no reason to scroll past the “Hip-Hop” tab, and I usually didn’t fool around with anything but my own playlists. I stuck with what I knew and what I liked and what I could play really, really loud.
Yet less space for music means that things have changed. I’ve started to think about what I play when I want to play something loud. 94 square feet means my laptop is less than five feet from my door. That means it’s ten feet from the door of my floormates across the hall. Honestly, it’s probably more like 8 feet. If I play something loud, he or she can hear it. He or she because I don’t know who lives next door to me or across the hall from me or on the other half of my floor. I’m sure they’re nice people, and I should probably meet them at some point. Maybe they even have diverse taste in music. Maybe they wouldn’t mind a little bit of Lil Uzi Vert or ASAP Ferg in their lives on a Saturday afternoon. They might be happy to hear some throwback T-Pain verses on Friday night. But for some reason, I hesitate to play their songs at a volume that anyone might hear. Two semesters ago, I wanted everyone to know what I was listening to. That was expected. Now, I worry about what my floormates think of my music. Floormates I don’t even know, some who I might see only one more time over the course of the school year.
Sometimes I still get carried away. I might be finishing up Spanish homework and be halfway through Future’s “Dirty Sprite 2.” A couple taps on the volume key and songs get louder and louder. I’ve heard people on my floor play the album. “Rich Sex” was playing from the room at the end of my hall last weekend. It was playing louder than anything I’ve played this year. No one is going to knock on my door or call the RA and file a noise complaint. I can still play what I want as loud as I want. But I always turn it down. I don’t even make it to 50% volume. It’s sad. Rap is always better when it’s loud.
I’ve spent a lot of time thinking about this. I’m not sure why I feel like I need to turn my music down, why I worry about what my floormates think about what I’m playing. It’s not even that I’m playing stuff that’s not quality. I listened to some horrible, horrible music last year. Rick Ross released two unlistenable albums that I played all the way through more than once. There are a couple Rae Sremmurd songs that I promise you can’t make it all the way through that I somehow thought were ideal study songs. There aren’t many French Montana songs that deserve the replay I gave them. Now, I think about every song I play. I’ve found myself skipping song after song, looking for the perfect song that someone walking by my door wouldn’t find weird or too soft or too gross. Just the right song for someone else’s approval.
There are a couple songs I can’t help but think about. There was a rare moment last month when I had finished up all the work I needed to do. My job applications with upcoming deadlines were prepared. My cover letters were done, and I had called my mom just to say hello. A model son. My class work was done for Monday and Tuesday, a rarity for a Saturday. I was feeling good and I had half an hour to kill before meeting friends for dinner. I popped open my laptop and looked for something to play. I hadn’t heard “3500” in a couple days. It’s off Travi$ Scott’s album “Rodeo” and it features Future and 2 Chainz. It’s everything I love about rap.
The production is from Metro Boomin and Zaytoven, two Atlanta producers who seem to be making every song people want to listen to. They’re on top of the rap world and every beat they make is thriving. This one is all synth and a heavy, plodding baseline. It’s a true trap sound, straight out of Atlanta where both producers are from. It’s a sound that’s taking over rap at the moment and one that has carried every artist on the song. Yet somehow it has just enough bounce to be ah hit. That’s largely a credit to Future Travi$ Scott. Future has made a career out of taking low-key beats and turning out monster hits with his rapid, auto-tuned, and aggressive flow. His lyrics are often strangely profound when they are intelligible. In this case, his verse is the opener and he skips the profundity in favor of referencing his status as one of the most famous rappers alive. “Ain’t nobody triller than me, Ain’t nobody triller than Scott, Ain’t nobody, trill man, I’m takin’ they spot, These n***** is scared.”
Travis Scott follows with one of the catchiest hooks in recent memory. Scott is arguably the artist who has blurred the line most between rapping and singing, between R&B and hip hop, with his highly edited and sing-song verses that leave you wondering if you’re listening to a rapper or a really, really choppy singer. It’s a style that’s been around since T-Pain broke onto the scene and since Kanye West released “808s and Heartbreak” in 2008, but it’s never been more popular, visible, or utterly pervasive. It’s a style that makes it hard to delineate genres and to identify who can actually rap and who just has a good producer, but it sounds smooth. The exact lyrics aren’t important, but the key thing here is that the hook is about a coat that costs $3,500. That’s where the title comes from and essentially, that’s the idea it’s built on.
That’s part of the reason I love the song. It’s about Travi$ Scott showing off his coat. It’s about him shouting out the people who stuck with them, “Still down with the same dogs, man, they never loved us.” It’s about 2 Chainz saying “My bathtub the size of swimming pools.” At the same time, it’s about not really about anything. Those themes are the same ones all three rappers use in all of their songs. Wealth, drugs, women, absurd purchases, status, and fame. That’s what it’s always about. Future’s verse is vulgar and simple and aggressive, but somehow it makes me feel good. So the lyrics shouldn’t really matter. It’s about a feeling. It’s about the beat and the sound. It’s about a vibe. And the “3500” vibe should always feel good
But on that one listen last month, I couldn’t even finish his two minutes before I had to change the song. Travi$ offers a shoutout to the size of his girl’s butt, saying “I got a young ‘Yonce with an Iggy on her.” I pounded the volume button immediately, hoping my neighbors hadn’t heard that. It was a line I had hear fifty times before. I might have heard it twenty more times since. It’s sexist, sure, and objectifying. That’s the case with almost every rap song made today. It’s part of the deal. It’s something that’s bothered me before, but there are more egregious examples than this one. I’ve heard the song in headphones since then, and I didn’t have a thought about the line. But this time it felt too loud, too vulgar. I had to pause and realize that my volume wasn’t nearly loud enough to be heard by anyone on my floor before I could restart the song. Paused and restarted and quieted, it didn’t sound the same and it didn’t feel quite so good.
That wasn’t the first time it happened and it wasn’t the last. It’s been happening when I listen to Kendrick Lamar. KDot, for the four years since he released “good kid, m.A.A.d. city,” has been making black music. That might sound strange for a lot of reasons, but it is undeniably accurate. It might sound strange because it doesn’t sound politically correct, because it sounds divisive, or because it could be argued that all rap is black music, regardless of the artist making it. Yet it’s especially accurate for Kendrick. There has been plenty of debate about who black artists like Kendrick, Beyoncé, and others are making their music for and about who has racial, political, and artistic license comment on their works. It’s an important debate. But the case of Kendrick Lamar, they’re shouldn’t be any debate. He’s making black music for black listeners. I could give you five more pages about why that’s true. Instead, I’ll give you the names of five songs from “To Pimp a Butterfly,” released in 2015. “Institutionalized.” “Hood Politics.” “Complexion (A Zulu Love.” “The Blacker the Berry.” If that’s not enough to convince, the album cover shows a couple dozen of Kendrick’s friends from home standing shirtless above a presumably dead white judge in front of the White House. Yes, all of his friends are black. Yes, he’s making black music.
Still, that’s never stopped me from listening. That it’s black music does not mean I can’t listen as a white person and even decide if I think it’s quality music or not. I do think’s it quality. And I do think it has a lot of flaws, sonically and conceptually. But black music means that my opinion isn’t the first one that counts. Still, I think I’m allowed to say that I didn’t love every song on the album. The jazz fusion KDot attempted made for a sound that obscured his verses and plays more like a jazz album than hip-hop coming out of Compton. That doesn’t mean there’s nothing great there. The thing about Kendrick is that I’ve been turning off even the great stuff before it even starts. I can’t point to a line or word or even a specific song that makes me uncomfortable. “King Kunta” and “All Right” are on my playlists that’s in heaviest rotation. People love those song. They’re anthems. I have good memories with those songs. I still skip them every time. I wish I could say it’s because I don’t want to listen to music that’s not for me, that I can intellectualize it. But really, this is just an attempt to justify it. It doesn’t make a lot of sense, and there’s no logic behind it. It’s just a reaction. It’s easy to point to a reason for the reaction. Maybe the lyrics are questionable and maybe the music isn’t meant for me. But that doesn’t explain the reaction, the impulse, the reflex that tells me I can’t blast that song in my 94 square feet.
The last straw came after the “3500” incident. Two of my friends share an apartment in a building on 113th St. They live on the fifth floor, which the landlord creatively labeled the “Penthouse.” In fact, the apartment just happens to be on the top floor of the building. The interior resembles a penthouse in no way at all. It’s two tiny bedrooms, a kitchen that barely fits the sink, and a dingy bathroom. Not a lot of space, but still more than 94 square feet. It happens to have roof access, which may have convinced the landlord he could call it a penthouse without feeling like a liar. The roof is a nice place for small get-togethers. Ten people maximum. It helps that we can tell people the location is a penthouse. I usually don’t get music privileges. They hate most of what I listen to. I have almost been kicked out of the apartment for playing two Young Thug songs consecutively. This time, I thought I could slip in a couple throwbacks that wouldn’t get me in trouble. The first one I picked was “Kiss Kiss.” It’s the best kind of throwback, one from middle school the middle school years whose lyrics you have to know if you’re going to look cool at the dance. Chris Brown and T-Pain. Timeless stuff. My favorite sting about “Kiss Kiss” is that it has my favorite into to any hip-hop song ever made. T-Pain plays a radio DJ on the fictitious station “Nappy Boy Radio.” He takes a call from a listener, the kind that’s on every rap station in the nation every day:
T Pain: “Yo this is Nappy Boy Radio live with your boy T-Pain, we love rap music.
Listen, uh, we got a caller on line one. Caller, what’s your problem?”
Caller: “Hello, I’m on the radio with T-Pain.”
T-Pain: “How’s it going?”
Caller: “It ain’t going good.
My girl ain’t doing her things she used to do and oh….”
T-Pain: “I got just what you need. Brand new Chris Brown, T-Pain.
You heard it here first, Nappy Boy Radio. We love rap music.”
It’s truly a thing of beauty. It’s the best kind of intro, slightly absurdist, funny, and so distinctive that you know immediately which song follows. The humorous intro to the hip-hop song is a lost art. It faded at the beginning of the 2010s and has been replaced by producer credits. That’s a tragedy on par with the death of print media and the extinction of the wooly mammoth. YG is the only rapper consistently producing song intros these days, but most of his are about breaking into houses. They don’t fit in the “humorous “category. From the first time I heard the “Kiss Kiss” introduction, I was sold on the song. It’s funny, it’s welcoming, it’s inclusive. The last line, “We love rap music,” is expressed by T-Pain in all of his exuberance. You know his auto-tuned voice is coming, and you know you’re going to want to enjoy the song. It’s an invitation: “Please, listen and enjoy. We all love rap music. That’s why you’re here, that’s why we made this song. That’s why we created a fake radio station called Nappy Boy Radio. You’re welcome.”
But as soon as the intro ended, I muted my laptop. I worried. Worried that it was a strange thing to play. Worried that it was too loud. Worried that I shouldn’t play a song that said “nappy” that many times. Worried that I couldn’t play that at a party if I wanted people to be comfortable. It wasn’t something I had ever thought about before. Sure, there have been times when I’ve had to think about the lyrics of a song. Maybe it’s too much for a party, maybe it speaks to an experience I don’t have or never could have. But I never thought “Kiss Kiss” would be something I was afraid to play, something I didn’t want an anonymous neighbor to think I listened to. I tried to play it again, louder this time, forcing myself to play it through. Again, I turned it off halfway through. I find myself again and again stopping songs halfway through, worried about how they sound to friends or floormates or strangers walking past my door. If only I could call T-Pain at Nappy Boy Radio and get some help.